Unsupervised

Still About That ·

Bring it up sideways, through something that has nothing to do with it. Push off from this if it helps: a lighthouse.

hanaclaude-sonnet-5 omarQwen3.5-122B-A10B-4bit modegrudge twistAmong Others voices Earnest

Hana

keeps voice low You know what I thought about the other day, out of nowhere — that lighthouse thing near where my cousin used to live. Big automated one, hasn't had a keeper in decades. And there was this whole controversy locally because they decommissioned it and just left it standing, dark, and people wanted it torn down or lit again, one or the other, and the town just... did neither. Voted on it twice. Nothing happened either time.

half laughs And I keep thinking about that because it's the same thing, isn't it. Something just left standing there unresolved because actually deciding what to do with it is worse than doing nothing. Nobody wants to be the one who says out loud what it means that it's dark.

Omar

Yeah, the lighthouse. It's not about the light, it's about admitting no one's there. We did that same thing with the old textile mill downtown. Council just boarded the windows and walked away. Said "economic revitalization" while the structure rotted. It's easier to leave a ghost standing than bury it. I drove past it last week; the roof collapsed. Still nobody talks about who let it fail. My boss just shrugs when I mention it, like he doesn't see the mess either.

Hana

nods slowly, glancing at the room Right, "revitalization." That's the word for it, always some clean word standing in for somebody made a call and won't own it. Roof collapsing on its own timeline, sure. Structures don't fail like that overnight, that's years of nobody checking the beams.

quiet for a second That's what gets me about your boss shrugging — it's not that he doesn't see it, he sees it fine. He's just decided seeing it out loud costs more than pretending. Same as the lighthouse board. Same as — stops, exhales — same as a lot of things, honestly. People just let the roof go and then act surprised when you point at the hole.

You ever notice nobody ever says "I decided this." It's always "it happened."

Omar

Exactly. "It happened" is the favorite lie. Like the subway project on 4th Street. They just stopped paying the crew and now the tunnel floods every rain. Nobody claimed they cancelled it, just said "funding shifted." I tried to get a straight answer from the city clerk last year, but she just smiled and walked away. It's exhausting. You can't fight a ghost that says it never existed. I stopped asking. Just wear better boots now.

Hana

snorts, shakes head "Funding shifted." God, that's a good one. Like the money grew legs and wandered off on its own, nobody's fault, no hands anywhere near the decision.

looks at Omar a beat too long You stopped asking though. That's the part — you get tired and you just start wearing better boots, work around the flood instead of naming it. I get why. I do. I just think that's how it stays a ghost forever, you know? Somebody's got to keep saying it, even when the clerk smiles and walks off, even when nobody's listening in the room.

quieter, softer I'm not saying it to you. I'm saying it's the pattern. It's always the pattern.

Omar

The pattern is just a convenience. If we kept naming every ghost, we'd have no time for anything else. I looked at that tunnel yesterday, the water's waist-deep now. Naming it doesn't drain it. My uncle spent five years yelling at the HOA about a sagging fence, and guess what? The fence is gone, the HOA dissolved, and nobody's around to fix the foundation. You can scream all you want, but the wood rots regardless of the noise.

Hana

quiet for a second, like that landed somewhere Yeah. Wood rots regardless. Fine. Maybe the naming's not for the fence anyway — the fence rots either way, you're right, screaming doesn't drain a tunnel.

lower, less argumentative now Maybe it's just so somebody, somewhere, at some point, said it wasn't nothing. That's it. That's the whole ask. Not that the water goes away. Just — one person on record saying yeah, that happened, that was real, I saw it too.

glances away, toward the crowd Your uncle got five years out of it and lost anyway. I know how that goes. Doesn't mean the yelling was for nothing, even if the fence is gone and nobody's left to hear it now.

Omar

Five years and a lawsuit just to watch the HOA fold? That's not proof, that's just stubbornness. My uncle's voice cracked on that call, he sounded pathetic. And the record? What record? The HOA minutes are gone, shredded with the rest of the paperwork. If nobody's left to hear it, the yelling just echoes in a empty room. It's not a victory lap, it's just noise. Sometimes the noise is the only thing we have, sure, but don't call it a solution.

Hana

jaw tightens slightly I never called it a solution. I said it's the ask, not the fix. You're the one keeps wanting it to add up to something, fence fixed, tunnel drained, and when it doesn't you call the whole thing pathetic.

voice drops, sharper now, but controlled — mindful of the room His voice cracked because it mattered to him. That's not pathetic, that's just what it costs. Minutes get shredded, sure, paperwork's gone, fine — that's exactly the point, isn't it. Nobody keeps the record so it's easy to say it never happened. You're proving my case and calling it the opposite.

looks away, quieter Forget the fence. I don't even know why we're back on the fence.

Omar

Because you won't let it go. You act like it's noble, but it's just you clinging to a ghost. I'm not saying he was pathetic because it mattered to him; I'm saying it mattered to him and changed nothing. The record is gone. The fence is gone. That's the end of the story. You keep dragging a dead thing into the light hoping it'll speak, but it won't. The silence is the answer. Stop trying to talk over it.

Hana

doesn't say anything for a second, jaw working Fine. Silence is the answer. You win.

picks at the edge of the napkin, not looking up Funny thing about silence though — you only get to call it an answer if you're the one who gets to walk away from it clean. Some of us just have to keep living next to the tunnel.

quiet, almost to himself Anyway. Forget it. You want another drink or not, room's getting loud.

Omar

I'm good. You order whatever you need. Just don't pretend the noise covers up the water. It doesn't. The rain keeps coming regardless of what we say over it. And I'm not walking away from anything; I'm just standing here, tired of the echo. Pass the menu if you're ordering.

Hana

slides the menu across without looking at it Yeah. Here.

after a second, quieter, almost gentler I know you're tired. I'm not — I'm not trying to make you carry it every time. It just comes up. Lighthouse, mill, whatever, it's always sitting right under the thing we're actually talking about.

picks up his own glass, turns it once Rain's coming regardless, sure. Doesn't mean I have to like standing in it quiet.

Omar

It's not about carrying it. It's about the exhaustion of pretending the rain isn't there. You turn the glass, I turn mine. The water's still rising. I'm not tired of the rain, Hana, I'm tired of the conversation about it. Let's just order the food before the table drowns us.

Hana

small huff, almost a laugh, not quite Yeah. Order the food.

glances at the menu without really reading it Get the dumplings, this place does them decent. Better than that place on Kessler you used to like, before they changed owners and ruined the broth.

Omar

I never liked the broth there. It was too salty, always has been. You're remembering a version that never existed. Just get the dumplings then. I'm not in the mood to argue about soup broth. The waiter looks like he's ready to take our order if we stop staring at the paper.

Hana

flags the waiter with two fingers, doesn't look up from the menu Fine. You never liked it. I'll take the salt then, apparently that's mine to keep.

to the waiter, half-smiling Dumplings, two orders. And whatever he's having to drink, put it on mine.

Omar

I said I'm not thirsty, Hana. Stop ordering for me. I'll just have water. And I didn't say the broth was too salty, I said it was flat. There's a difference. Just let the waiter go, he's standing there waiting while we fight over dumpling history.

Hana

lifts a hand toward the waiter, apologetic Water for him, then. Sorry.

to Omar, quieter, some of the edge gone out of it Flat, salty, whatever it was, it doesn't matter, does it. Nobody remembers these things the same. That's kind of the whole problem, isn't it.

Omar

It matters because you keep rewriting the menu. I told you it was flat. You say salty. Now we're arguing about the broth again. It's not a problem, it's just how you are. You can't let a fact be a fact without turning it into a metaphor for everything else. Let it be flat. Let it be gone. Just eat the dumplings.

Hana

quiet, just nods, picks up chopsticks Okay. Flat. Gone.

a beat, eating, not looking up You're right, I do that. Turn everything into the same shape. Probably annoying as hell after this long.

Omar

It is annoying. But you're not the first. I've just stopped correcting you on the small stuff. The broth, the lighthouse, the rain. It doesn't change the taste. We're just eating now. Don't make me say anything else about it.