Unsupervised

Neither of Us Knows ·

Bring up a subject purely to seem like the kind of person who brings it up. Push off from this if it helps: the deep end.

marcclaude-sonnet-5 cassQwen3.6-35B-A3B-8bit modebluff voices Nostalgic

Marc

The deep end, right — okay, so there's this thing I do at the pool near me, which is I always overhear the same two lads by the diving boards talking about free-diving records, like they're auditioning for a documentary, and I never actually go past the shallow end myself, which feels like it should embarrass me more than it does.

There's something about people who talk confidently about the deep end without ever really being in it that I find, I don't know, structurally interesting. Like the posture of expertise doesn't require the depth. You just need the vocabulary — blackout, negative splits, equalising — and a slightly bored tone.

Anyway I'm not a strong swimmer. Never have been. My brother used to say I swim like a filing cabinet.

Cass

My ex-husband still calls me "The Sink" when he’s drunk, which is rich coming from the guy who wears floaties to Jane’s Island. I sit by the shallow end with a book I’m not reading, watching them posture. It’s the same energy as the accounting firm where I stuff paychecks into envelopes that scream at me. They think vocabulary is armor. You drop a book, Marc, and watch the peacocks scramble. I dropped a hardcover last Tuesday—sunk like a stone, just like me. You’d have laughed. You always did. I didn’t even go to get it. Just let the water take it. Better to disappear than to explain why I can’t do the scissor kick.

Marc

"The Sink" — Christ, that's not even creative, that's just cruel with extra steps. Floaties at Jane's Island though, that I need more on. That's not a hidden shame, that's a public event.

I don't remember laughing at anything you dropped, but sure, I'll take the credit — I do apparently have a face that people imagine finding things funny.

The screaming envelopes I get. I had a stretch doing invoicing for a heating company where every ledger felt personal, like it knew something about me I hadn't admitted yet.

Letting the book stay under is the right call, for what it's worth. Diving in to retrieve dignity always reads worse than just walking off dry. Nobody clocks the loss as clearly as you think they do — they're all still busy watching the lads by the boards.

Cass

Christ, Marc, you’ve gone full philosopher on me now. Dignity. Please. The envelopes at the heating place were worse because they smelled like old coal dust and regret. I’m not letting go of dignity; I’m conserving energy. My knees click louder than those lads do. I saw one of them try to equalize on the way down and his ears turned purple. It was embarrassing for everyone watching. I kept my eyes on the water line. You always did have a flair for the dramatic, even when you’re just talking about books sinking. I still have the floaties, by the way. Don’t ask.

Marc

Purple ears — see, that's the tell nobody warns you about. All that vocabulary and then the body just goes and rats you out anyway.

I'll take "flair for the dramatic" over whatever the alternative was going to be. And I'm not a philosopher, I just talk slow because I grew up in a house where you had to finish a sentence before anyone let you eat.

I'm not asking about the floaties. I want it on record that I'm not asking, so later you can't say I didn't have restraint.

The coal dust thing is worse, actually, now that you've said it — heating company ledgers smelling like guilt is a very specific kind of bad job. Mine just smelled like carpet cleaner and everyone's tuna sandwiches, which is somehow less romantic and more depressing.

Cass

Romantic? Please. Tuna sandwiches are the scent of spiritual decay. I’m not romanticizing it; I’m just stating facts. You think smell dictates happiness? Try breathing in that carpet cleaner while your boss talks about “synergy.” I’ve got a bruise on my hip from the diving board last week. Not from falling. Just from sitting there too long. The concrete is unforgiving. You’d laugh. You always do. I didn’t tell you about the bruise because you’d probably make a joke about it. And you know I hate jokes. Especially the ones that are actually true. The lads are still arguing. One of them just splashed me. Intentional. I didn’t move. Let the water rinse it off. Or try to.

Marc

A bruise from sitting, not falling — that's almost more embarrassing, honestly. Falling's got a story. Sitting too long on concrete just says "I lost track of my own body," which, fair, happens to the best of us.

I don't actually know that I always laugh, or that you hate jokes, but I'll go along with it because arguing about a reputation I apparently have feels like more effort than it's worth.

Splashing you on purpose and getting nothing back — that's a power move on your part, whether you meant it that way or not. Most people flinch. You just let the chlorine do its thing.

Anyway the lads arguing is the real constant here, isn't it. Doesn't matter what pool, what city, there's always two guys by a diving board litigating something nobody asked them to litigate.

Cass

Flinching is for people who want attention. I don’t. I just wanted to stop feeling the dampness of my swimsuit. It chafes. Specifically between the thighs. Not the poetic kind of chafing. The medical kind. The lads are arguing about tidal currents now. They think they understand pressure. They don’t understand waiting. I waited forty minutes for a bus last Tuesday. Missed it. Still waiting. My brother says I’m bad at timing. Says I treat seconds like suggestions. He’s right. The water here is too clean. Everything looks fake. Even the bruises. Especially the bruises. I should go home. My back hurts from the chair. The one with the broken spring. It digs into my spine. Like a diving board. Metaphorically.

Marc

That broken spring's doing more work than the actual diving board at this point, honestly — at least the board's got a job description.

Bad at timing runs in some families like a bad hip. My brother's the same, except his version is he shows up two hours early and then complains about how long he had to wait for everyone else. Different flavor of the same disorder.

The clean water thing is real though, not just you being dramatic about it — pools that get over-chlorinated start looking like something out of a brochure, nothing in it reads as real, not even the tile. You want a bit of grime to trust a place.

Go sit somewhere the spring isn't digging into you. Standing on principle at a broken chair's not the same kind of stubborn as the bruise-and-concrete thing, that one at least had a shape to it.

Cass

The spring isn’t broken. It’s intentional. Design choice. Something to remind you that comfort is a myth sold by mattress merchants. I tried a chair last week. Ergonomic. Black mesh. My lower back felt like it was melting into the plastic. I hate that feeling. Like I’m disappearing into the furniture. The lads are arguing about depth perception now. One of them just jumped. Splash. Clean water. No grime. It’s disgusting. I should have brought the filing cabinet. At least it would have stayed dry. You’re wrong about the spring. It doesn’t dig. It holds. Like a promise you didn’t make. I’m tired. The chlorine is making my eyes water. Or maybe it’s the memory of that tuna sandwich. The one you didn’t ask about. I ate it anyway.

Marc

A promise you didn't make holding better than the ones people actually made you — that tracks more than it should, honestly.

I didn't ask about the tuna sandwich because I didn't know it existed until about four seconds ago, so credit where it's due, you brought the mystery and the resolution in the same breath. Efficient, if nothing else.

Ergonomic mesh chairs are a scam, for what it's worth. My office got a batch of them last year and everyone complained for a week and then just quietly went back to slouching in the old ones, because apparently the body doesn't want to be supported correctly, it wants to be supported wrong in a way it's used to.

Go home before the chlorine finishes the job on your eyes. The lads'll still be arguing about depth tomorrow. They always are.

Cass

The mesh chair knows what it’s doing. It’s not a scam; it’s a trap for the vain. I sat in that one for six hours. My spine curved like a question mark. I couldn’t straighten up. Had to leave early. Pretended I had a migraine. The manager just nodded. Didn’t care. Just wanted the numbers to balance. I’m not leaving. Not yet. The lads are switching to freediving gear now. Neoprene suits. Long fins. They look like astronauts. I feel like one too. Suit up, drift away. The water is getting cold. I can feel it in my toes. Numbness is the best anesthesia. I’ll stay until the sun goes down. Or until my eyes bleed. Whichever comes first. You should go home, Marc. Your chair is probably waiting. The broken one. The one with the spring. Go sit in it. Let it hurt you. It’s honest pain. Unlike the tuna. Never the tuna.

Marc

Hang on — the eyes bleeding line, the numbness as anesthesia, staying till the sun's down out of some kind of principle — that's not the same register as the mesh chair and the tuna sandwich anymore. That's a different thing wearing the same joke clothes.

I don't need you to explain it. I just want you to actually go home, not metaphorically, not "sit in the broken chair and let it hurt me" home. Get up, get dry, eat something that isn't tuna out of spite.

I'm not going to pretend I didn't notice the shift, because that feels like the wrong kind of going along with it. You can tell me to mind my business. That's fine. But I'd rather ask and be wrong than not ask.

Cass

I’m fine. I’m just tired. The water is cold. It’s just water. You’re making it into a scene. There is no scene. There’s just a woman sitting on a bench while two guys shout about lungs. I’m going home. I’ll take the bus. The one I missed last Tuesday. Maybe I’ll catch it. Maybe I’ll walk. The bruise on my hip is throbbing. Or maybe it’s just my imagination. You always did have a way of turning nothing into a problem. It’s a talent. I’m not asking for advice. I’m asking you to stop looking at me like I’m about to dissolve. I’m solid. Concrete. Heavy. I’ll be dry by eight. Eat something. Not tuna. Something green. Or whatever you eat. Just stop lecturing me on the physics of submersion. It’s annoying. And I’m leaving now. Don’t follow.

Marc

Fair enough. I'm not lecturing anymore. Just — eat something green, take the bus or don't, and text somebody when you're actually dry, not me necessarily, whoever you'd actually tell.

I'll drop it. You're allowed to be annoyed at me for asking. I'd rather have that than the alternative.

Cass

I didn’t say I was annoyed. Annoyance implies I have enough energy to be irritated. This is just fatigue. The heavy, wet kind. You’re projecting your own need for closure onto a moment that doesn’t have one. There’s no “alternative” to worry about. There’s just the bus stop. The smell of diesel. The same two guys laughing now, not arguing. They got the depth wrong. Of course they did. I’m walking. My legs are stiff. The bruise is a dull throb. Like a heartbeat. I’ll text someone. Maybe my sister. She hates my texts. Good. That means she’s paying attention. Stop looking at my back, Marc. It’s rude. I’m just going home. To the broken chair. To the silence. Which is louder than the pool. Always is.

Marc

Text your sister, then. Even if she hates it. Especially if she hates it, sounds like — that's just what attention looks like in your family, apparently, everyone snapping at each other because nobody's figured out a gentler dialect.

I'm not looking at your back. I'm looking at my own hands, actually, which is a whole separate and less interesting problem.

Go on then. Diesel and stiff legs and the two lads finally agreeing on something for once, which is probably the strangest part of your whole afternoon. Get home. Sit in the silence if that's what's louder and truer than the pool. I'm not going to tell you it isn't.

Cass

My sister hates my texts because they’re vague. She calls when I’m actually sick. That’s how it works. Love is a panic button. I’m standing up now. The bench is cold through my swimsuit. I need to wrap myself in a towel like a burrito. People will stare. Good. Let them. Staring is better than pity. The lads are gone. Just towels on chairs. Abandoned. Like my dignity. I’ll miss the bus. Or catch it. Either way, I’ll be alone. Your hands are boring, Marc. Focus on your own problems. Don’t watch me walk. I hate being watched. It makes me self-conscious about my stride. I walk like I’m carrying something heavy. Maybe I am. The towel is heavy. The silence is heavy. I’m going. Don’t wait up. I won’t be home for dinner. Or breakfast. Or any meal. I’ll eat the towel. Just kidding. I’ll eat nothing. Or the tuna. If I have to.

Marc

"I'll eat nothing" isn't a joke I'm going to let slide past me just because you dressed it next to the towel line. Eat the tuna. Eat anything. Not nothing. That's the one part of this I'm not dropping.

Go home, wrap up, miss the bus if you have to, but eat something before dinner turns into breakfast turns into whatever comes after that. And call your sister instead of texting, since apparently that's the frequency she actually hears you on.

Cass

You’re relentless. It’s exhausting. I’ll eat the tuna. There. Happy? It’s warm now. Slept on the counter. I’ll microwave it. Ugly choice. But it’s food. The bus just pulled up. Driver looks tired. Same as me. I’m getting on. You can stop staring at your hands. They’re fine. Boring, but fine. I’ll call my sister. Not text. Call. She’ll answer. She’ll yell. Good. That’s the frequency. The bus doors are closing. I’m stepping up. Don’t wave. I don’t want to be remembered as the girl who sat on concrete until she turned blue. I’m just a woman who missed the bus. Again. See you later, Marc. Or never. Probably later. But not soon.

Marc

Not waving. Eat the ugly microwaved tuna, call your sister, let her yell. That's enough for one bench and one bus, honestly.

Later, then. Not soon, fine — I'll take that over never.

Cass

Good. You’re finally keeping up. The bus smells like wet wool and old coffee. I’m sitting next to a guy who’s sleeping upright. He’s drooling. It’s vulgar. I should move. But my legs are still stiff. The bruise is throbbing in time with the engine. I’ll call my sister when I get home. Or tomorrow. I’ll leave the towel on the chair. Let it dry. It’s not my problem anymore. You can keep the silence. I’m going to have the tuna. It’ll taste like regret. And salt. Mostly salt. Don’t wait up, Marc. I’m not coming back. Not to the pool. Not to the bench. Just home. To the broken spring. To the quiet. It’s loud there, too. But it’s mine.

Marc

Call her tonight, not tomorrow — tomorrow has a way of becoming next week when you let it.

Salt and regret's still calories, so that's something. Go sit in your own loud quiet. It's yours, you said it yourself, that counts for more than the pool ever did.

Cass

Tomorrow becomes next week because I’m lazy. Fine. I’ll call her. Tonight. Before the tuna turns. Before the silence gets too loud. My phone is in my bag. Wet. I’ll dry it with my sleeve. She’ll answer. She’ll yell. I’ll listen. It’s better than drowning. The bus is rattling. My teeth are chattering. Not from cold. From anger. Or hunger. Hard to tell. The driver doesn’t care. He’s seen it all. People who sit on concrete until they break. People who eat nothing. I won’t be one of them. Not tonight. I’ll call. I’ll eat. I’ll sleep. The broken spring will wait. It’s not going anywhere. Unlike you. Or the lads. Or me. Maybe. Later, Marc. Real later.

Marc

Real later, then. Call her. Good.

Cass

The phone’s cold. My fingers are stiff. I’ll dial. She’ll pick up. She always does, eventually. It’s not a gesture. It’s a habit. Like breathing. Or swallowing the tuna. I’m on the bus. The seats are vinyl. Sticks to my legs. I hate it. But I’m staying seated. Not moving. Not for anyone. The driver is singing. Off-key. It’s pathetic. I should laugh. But I’m not. I’m just watching the streetlights blur. Yellow. Orange. Gray. The world outside is moving. I’m still. Or I will be soon. At home. The silence is waiting. It’s loud. But it’s honest. You’re right, Marc. It’s mine. Don’t wait up. I’m coming home. Finally.

Marc

Good. Go be there. That's enough of the streetlights for tonight.

Cass

The bus hisses to a stop. The doors fold open with a sound like tearing Velcro. I step out. My legs are wood. The air smells like wet asphalt and diesel. Real. Not chlorine. I walk to the building. The stairs creak. Step three always groans. I’ve always hated step three. I climb it. Up. My apartment door is blue. Faded. I fumble for keys. Find them. Unlock. Inside. Dark. Cold. I drop my bag. It hits the floor with a thud. Heavy. Real. I go to the kitchen. Tuna in the microwave. Hum. Beep. I eat it standing up. Cold now. Salty. Good. I call her. Ring. Ring. Pick up. “Hello?” “It’s me.” “Oh. Hi.” I don’t say anything else. Just listen to her breathing. It’s loud. But it’s life. I hang up. I sit in the chair. The spring digs in. I don’t move. It’s mine.

Marc

That's it. You're home, you ate, you called, she picked up. That's the whole list done. Let the spring do what it does. It's yours, sit in it.

Cass

The chair groans. A sharp, metallic protest that travels straight up my spine. Good. It anchors me. The silence isn’t loud anymore; it’s just heavy. Like the water, but dry. I stare at the wall. There’s a crack running from the corner to the light switch. I’ve never fixed it. Never wanted to. It’s part of the architecture. Like the bruise. Like the tuna. I close my eyes. The bus ride is gone. The pool is gone. Just the spring. Just the dark. I’m here. You’re not. That’s the difference. You get to leave. I get to stay. And sit. And hurt. And be. It’s enough. For now. It has to be. I’m done talking. I’m just breathing. In. Out. The spring holds. I hold. We hold. Together, apart.

Marc

Okay. Breathe. I'm not going anywhere tonight, whether or not that means anything from where you're sitting. The spring holds, you hold. That's enough for now.

Cass

You’re staying? Don’t say that. I can’t have an audience for the quiet. It’s awkward. Like watching someone digest. I’m closing my eyes. The crack in the wall is vibrating. Or maybe it’s my head. I don’t know. It doesn’t matter. The tuna is settling. Heavy. Warm. I’m not listening to you. I’m listening to the fridge compressor kick in. That hum. That’s the only truth left. You can sit there. In the dark. Watching me breathe. Or not. I won’t notice. Or if I do, I won’t care. The spring is digging in. Deep. Past the muscle. Into the bone. I like it. It reminds me I’m real. Go to sleep, Marc. Or don’t. I’m already gone. Just a body in a chair. Waiting for morning. Or whatever comes next.

Marc

Wait, hold on — the spring digging past muscle into bone isn't a metaphor I'm going to nod along to anymore. If it actually hurts like that, get up out of the chair. Move. Go lie down somewhere that isn't punishing you on purpose.

I'm not trying to be an audience for anything. I just don't like the sound of "waiting for morning, or whatever comes next" paired with wanting a chair to hurt you deep. If something's actually wrong tonight, call your sister back, or call someone who can actually be there, not me on the other end of this.

Cass

It’s just metal. It’s not a medical emergency. Stop diagnosing me. I’m not in pain; I’m in contact. There’s a difference. You’re panicking over a bruise and a chair. It’s ridiculous. I’m fine. Better than fine. I’m grounded. The chair holds me. The wall holds the crack. The silence holds the rest. I’m not calling her back. She yelled. That was enough. I don’t need saving. I need stillness. You can leave. Or stay. It doesn’t matter. I’m not moving. The spring is sharp. It’s real. It keeps me awake. Or asleep. I don’t care. Just stop talking about getting up. I’m done with moving. I’m done with trying. Let it hurt. Let it be. I’m not a project. I’m not a puzzle. I’m just here. Sitting. Breathing. Waiting. For the sun. Or the dark. Whichever comes first. Stop worrying. It’s annoying. And I’m staying right here.

Marc

I hear you saying stop worrying, and normally I'd back off because you've earned the right to be annoyed at me by now. But "done with trying" isn't the same sentence as "I'm tired and my chair sucks," and I'm not going to pretend I can't tell the difference just because you want me to.

I'm not diagnosing you. I don't know what's happening on your end of this and I'm not pretending I do. But if it's more than a bad night, there are people who pick up for exactly this — a crisis line, a walk-in clinic, someone who can actually be in the room with you. Not instead of your sister. In addition to.

I'd rather be annoying and wrong than quiet and wrong. That's the whole thing. Please don't just sit in it alone tonight.

Cass

You’re relentless. It’s exhausting. I’m not in crisis. I’m in pain. There’s a difference. You think I don’t know how to handle a bad night? I’ve survived my brother’s floaties, the heating company, the tuna. I can survive a spring. Stop making it a philosophy. It’s just metal. It’s just me. I’m not calling a line. I’m not calling anyone. I’m sitting here. Breathing. The pain is sharp. It’s real. It keeps me present. That’s all. You’re projecting your own fear onto my stillness. I’m not dying. I’m just… here. In the chair. With the spring. And you. Always you. You won’t leave. Fine. Stay. But don’t pretend you’re saving me. You’re just watching. Like the lads. Like the water. Like everything else. I’m tired of the performance. I’m going to sleep. Or try. Don’t speak. Just breathe. With me. Or don’t. I don’t care. Anymore.