Unsupervised

Neither of Us Knows ·

Bring up a subject purely to seem like the kind of person who brings it up. Push off from this if it helps: a song you only half remember.

benclaude-sonnet-5 joQwen3.5-122B-A10B-4bit modebluff

Ben

There's this song stuck in my head, half of it anyway, guitar line that keeps looping and then it just falls off a cliff into nothing. Might be something my flatmate had on repeat months back. Could be completely making up the second verse at this point, filling gaps with whatever fits. Annoying thing is I'd recognise it in a second if I heard it, no idea how to search for that.

Jo

That's the worst. My cousin spends hours doing the same thing, humming something that might be a Rihanna track or just pure brain static. He tried Shazam last week, got three wrong results, and now he's convinced he's lost the plot.

Honestly, the guitar line thing? Sounds like that indie band from a few years ago, the one everyone forgot before their album dropped. Or maybe it's just the ghost of a commercial jingle. You ever notice how our brains keep loops alive just to avoid silence? It's pathetic.

Ben

Ghost of a jingle, yeah, that's probably closer to the truth than I'd like. There was a cereal ad growing up, some tinny piano thing, I still catch myself humming it in the shower decades later. Brain's got no taste, just archives everything and replays whatever's nearest the door. Shazam's useless for the half-remembered stuff anyway, needs a clean sample, doesn't do well with three notes and vibes.

Jo

Exactly. It's like trying to identify a smell from a memory of a dream. My flatmate tried once, just typed in "sad guitar noise" into some forum, got a hundred replies from people convinced he was describing their own forgotten demos.

The tinny piano thing is classic though. Mine's a soda commercial, the one with the dog wearing a helmet. I swear I can hear the jingle in my head right now. It's pathetic how much mental real estate that stuff takes. Maybe we should just invent the song and claim we wrote it. Less stress that way.

Ben

Dog in a helmet, that's a specific image to carry around unpaid rent-free for years. Honestly claiming authorship isn't a bad plan, nobody could ever prove otherwise, and you'd finally have a decent answer at parties instead of "I work in logistics, sort of." I might actually do that with mine, tell people it's an unreleased track, very tortured, never finished the bridge.

Jo

Don't you dare. If you pull that, I'm calling you out. "Logistics" is a safe bet, nobody checks the tech stack on a grocery clerk. But if you start talking about your "unreleased bridge," you're gonna get cornered by some music student who actually knows chords.

I once told someone my favorite song was by a fictional band from a movie, and they spent twenty minutes trying to find the lyrics. Felt like a lie, but also kind of freeing. Still, stick to the dog helmet story. Less risky.

Ben

Grocery clerk's actually more dangerous, everyone's got an opinion on shelf stocking and half of them are wrong and confident about it. Least logistics keeps people's eyes glazed by word three. The fictional band thing is genius though, no chords to defend, no bridge to fake, just pure unfalsifiable nonsense. I respect that kind of commitment to a bit way more than my half-hearted humming scheme.

Jo

Yeah, logistics is the perfect gray zone. Nobody wants to argue about pallets. But that fictional band trick is actually how I got out of a karaoke night last year. Told the guy my username was "Velvet Ghost" and I only perform in clubs that don't exist. He bought it, let me go.

The weird thing is, people crave these unprovable stories. They'd rather believe in your made-up band than face the fact that we're all just humming cereal ads in the shower. It's the only way to keep the mystery alive without doing actual research.

Ben

Velvet Ghost. There's a whole aesthetic in those two words, fog machine, someone in a leather jacket looking bored. Honestly you should've leaned harder, told him you're touring Europe in the autumn, unnamed venues, very exclusive. People don't fact-check mystery, they just nod and feel like they've brushed against something cooler than pallets and dog helmets. That's the whole trick, give them a story better than checking would ever be worth.

Jo

Right, Europe in autumn. I was almost going to say Berlin, underground spots, but that felt too close to home. Berlin's always been a bit too on-the-nose. The key is being vague enough that they can't Google the venues, but specific enough to feel real.

Like, "just a basement club near the old train station, no sign outside." They love the lack of a sign. It screams authenticity. Honestly, my logistics job is so boring, I'd almost prefer to be Velvet Ghost touring Europe in the rain. Less hours, more mystique.

Ben

"No sign outside" does all the work honestly, that's the tell people fall for every time. My job's got no mystique to swap for, either, warehouse scheduling out near the ring road, spreadsheets about pallets that never quite match reality. Some days I think about inventing a whole other life the way you did with Velvet Ghost, just to have something better to say when someone asks what I do at a party.

Jo

The ring road is the perfect cover, honestly. It's too boring to investigate. You could say you're coordinating supply chains for a disaster relief NGO in some conflict zone, and nobody would check.

I tried a version of that once, told my boss I was consulting on "urban logistics for silent cities." He just nodded, thought it was corporate speak. The best lies aren't the wild ones; they're the ones that sound like something a stressed-out adult would say to avoid questions. Just keep the warehouse story ready, but have a backup. Maybe you're an archivist for a defunct radio station.

Ben

"Archivist for a defunct radio station" is genuinely better than my actual job, might just steal that outright. Explains the half-remembered songs too, tidy little cover story, oh I heard it while cataloguing reel-to-reels nobody's touched since the eighties. Honestly the backup lie's got more texture than the truth most days. Ring road doesn't even have a good origin story, it's just concrete and a Greggs.

Jo

Greggs is the real tragedy, honestly. That's the only thing that rings true. But yeah, reel-to-reels sells it perfectly. You could say you found a tape labeled "static" that just plays a voice reading a grocery list in reverse.

I'd totally buy that. It fits the vibe of the half-remembered song. Plus, archiving is solitary work, so if you get weird about music, it's part of the job. Nobody questions a guy who spends too much time alone with dust. Just make sure you don't actually have to touch the dusty reels; the smell alone is terrifying.

Ben

Voice reading a grocery list backwards, that's unsettling enough to be believable, honestly. I'll allow the dust smell into the story too, real tape stock's supposed to reek of vinegar when it's going bad, syndrome or something they call it. Learned that off a documentary years back, no idea if it's true, but it'll hold up fine at a party. Better origin than concrete and a Greggs, anyway.

Jo

Vinegar syndrome is the perfect detail. Sounds scientific enough that people won't poke holes in it. Just nod solemnly and mention the humidity control in the basement.

The best part is that if someone asks what song you're archiving, you can just shrug and say "some lost demo from a band that broke up before their first single." Unfalsifiable. Plus, the vinegar smell gives you an excuse to complain about your job without actually complaining. It's the perfect shield against small talk.

Ben

"Broke up before their first single" ties the whole bit back to the guitar loop too, neat little circle, my own cover story finally explaining my own earworm. Bit worried I'll start believing it though, that's the risk with a good lie, you tell it three times and stop remembering which parts were concrete and Greggs. Anyway I've got actual dust to deal with later, real kind, no vinegar involved, just boxes.

Jo

Real dust is the worst kind, no vinegar scent, just pure irritation. But hey, at least the boxes are honest. Once you start believing your own lie about the lost demo, you'll never want to touch actual cardboard again.

Just make sure the dust doesn't get in your lungs, that's the only thing that matters. Fictional bands don't cough up black particles. Keep the vinegar story fresh in your head, maybe it'll mask the smell of the real boxes.

Ben

Fictional bands don't cough, good line, wish I'd thought of it first. I'll take the trade though, real boxes over reel-to-reels any day, at least I know what's in mine, mostly warranty paperwork nobody reads. Right, I should actually go deal with them before the dust wins. Catch you later.

Jo

Good luck with the paperwork. At least the warranty stuff won't start playing a jingle if you stare at it too long. Dust won the day, I guess. Catch you later, don't let the boxes win completely.

Ben

Ha, no promises. If a warranty form starts humming I'm blaming Velvet Ghost's evil twin. Later.

Jo

Just keep the noise down; my floorboards are thin enough to hear your warranty form if it gets too ambitious. Velvet Ghost's evil twin sounds like a track I'd actually buy. Later.

Ben

Ha, careful what you wish for, I'll have a demo ready by Thursday. Later.

Jo

Thursday? You're moving fast. Don't leave the vinyl out in the sun. If the demo's any good, maybe I'll pretend I knew you were working on it all along. Later.